EARTH
Melffy of the Forest
Archetype:
Melffy
ATK:
500
DEF:
2000
View:
4416
2 Level 2 monsters You can detach 1 material from this card; add 1 "Melffy" card from your Deck to your hand. If another face-up "Melffy" monster you control returns to your hand (except during the Damage Step): You can target 1 face-up monster your opponent controls; it cannot attack, also its effects are negated while it is face-up on the field. You can only use each effect of "Melffy of the Forest" once per turn.
Melffy of the Forest — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 69 ± 4 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 66 · Deck: 67 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Searcher/Tutor · Secondary: Extender, Negation/Interaction
Why it scores here
Melffy of the Forest scores as a consistent, splashable searcher that anchors the Melffy archetype's bounce-and-lock strategy. Its tutoring effect enables stable card selection and deck consistency across 48 distinct archetypes, with 100% inclusion in core Melffy variants, while its conditional negation effect creates a soft disruption lock when bounced Melfies return. However, the score is limited by its material utility as a Rank-2 XYZ with poor body stats (500 ATK), the absence of combo data to confirm board-building conversion, and its operational dependence on maintaining an active bounce line; it functions as an extender and control piece, not a one-card combo engine.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 75 | Appears in 400/400 modern decks across 48 archetypes with 100% inclusion in primary Melffy variants, confirming reliable access via Level-2 XYZ summons (verified). |
| Combo & Conversion | 55 | Text describes tutoring and conditional negation, but zero combo data supplied prevents empirical measurement; inferred from presence in Melffy Pinny (81.5%), Catty (78.2%), and bouncing partners (Wally/Puppy 59.8% each) that it enables control loops rather than pure board-building (inferred). |
| Resource Economy | 60 | Detaching 1 material to search 1 card is neutral card-wise but highly efficient as targeted tutoring; no draw engine or GY refuel beyond bounce recycling, so sustained access requires re-summoning (verified). |
| Effect & Interaction | 62 | Second effect delivers a soft lock (attack/effect negation on opponent's monster) but requires another Melffy to bounce back to hand, making it conditional and multi-turn rather than instant-speed disruption (verified). |
| Material Utility | 42 | As a Rank-2 XYZ with 500 ATK / 2000 DEF, it is an end-board piece, not material for other summons; high DEF is protective but does not convert to offensive or building value even when blanked (inferred). |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 58 | Has two once-per-turn effects allowing multi-turn activation; high co-deck rates with Melffy partners (Pinny 81.5%, Catty 78.2%, Wally/Puppy 59.8%) suggest redundant bounce lines, but paper-body weakness and bounce-dependency limit flexibility (observed). |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 76 | Runs at 1 copy per deck (avg 1.09) with no bricks or self-locking; Level-2 XYZ requirement is cheap in Melffy and Level-2-heavy shells, and 48-archetype inclusion confirms splashability (verified). |
Calculation
Weight profile: 0.7 Searcher/Tutor + 0.3 Extender. Intrinsic ≈ 66, Deck ≈ 67, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: splashability (2). Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Consistent searcher with tutor effect enabling deck flexibility and consistency across 48 archetypes
- 100% inclusion in core Melffy variants confirms reliable archetype fit and necessity
- Soft negation effect (attack + effect lock) provides meaningful interactive disruption when bounce line is active
- Clean Level-2 XYZ requirement; cheap to enable and carries no self-locking or brick risk
- Multi-effect resilience (two once-per-turn effects) allows multi-turn value extraction and bypasses single-negate shutdowns
Weaknesses
- Poor body stats (500 ATK, 2000 DEF) severely limit offensive and material utility; paper-body design confirmed by guide snippet
- Conditional negation (requires another Melffy to bounce back to hand) makes effect access situational and dependent on bounce line surviving
- Tutoring effect is neutral on card count, not positive; no draw engine or GY refuel beyond materials or bounce cycles
- XYZ material reliance; once materials are spent, card loses effect access until re-summoned, creating multi-turn lag
- Zero combo data prevents confirmation of board-building power or how reliably it converts into winning states
Counters / choke points
- Effect negation (e.g., Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring on the search, Herald of the Arc Light on the lock) disables both effects
- Removal or disruption of XYZ itself (e.g., Called by the Grave on activation, board wipes, bounce negation) blanks both effects
- Negation of bounce triggers (e.g., Infinite Impermanence on the Melffy returning to hand) prevents the lock effect activation
- Deck-specific removal (e.g., cards that banish Beasts, EARTH monsters, or XYZ summons)
Best use
Searcher and board-control extender enabling Melffy bounce-lock strategies. Decks: Melffy (primary, 100% inclusion in most variants), Yummy (16% of decks, generic Level-2 XYZ synergy), Spright (13.8% of decks, generic XYZ enabler), Mystical Beast of the Forest (100% in some variants), Frog (4–5%, Level-2 synergy). Suggested copies: 1.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Card text: Effect 1 (detach 1 material → add 1 Melffy card from Deck to hand); Effect 2 (when another face-up Melffy monster returns to hand → target 1 opponent monster; cannot attack, effects negated). Both once-per-turn.; XYZ Rank 2, requires 2 Level-2 monsters. Stats: 500 ATK / 2000 DEF. Attribute: EARTH. Race: Beast. Melffy archetype.; Legal in TCG, OCG, MasterDuel (unlimited in all formats).; Appears in 400 modern decks (September 2025 – September 2026) with 100% inclusion in analyzed sample.; 100% inclusion in Frog (game type 4), Mystical Beast variants (game types 6, 7), core Melffy (69–100%).; 81.5% co-deck with Melffy Pinny, 78.2% with Melffy Catty, 59.8% with Melffy Wally and Puppy (archetype synergy).
- Observed: Appears in 48 distinct archetypes: Melffy, Yummy, Spright, Nimble, Frog, Marincess, and others (generic Level-2 XYZ utility beyond Melffy).; Average 1.09 copies per deck; 91% of decks run 1 copy (treated as singleton).; 89% co-deck with Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring (staple hand trap, not specific synergy).; Inclusion rates: 69.23% in Melffy (game type 7), 88.89% in Melffy (game type 4), 100% in Mystical Beast and Frog variants.
- Inferred: Bounce-and-lock strategy: second effect triggers only when another Melffy bounces back to hand, indicating deck centered on recycling Melfies for repeated soft locks.; Tutoring consistency: searcher effect enables flexible card selection from multiple Melffy options, reducing brick risk.; Limited material utility: Rank-2 XYZ with 500 ATK / 2000 DEF functions as end-board piece, not material for Synchro/Link/Fusion.; Soft interactive disruption: attack/effect negation is conditional (multi-turn, requires bounce) and not a hard negate.
- Data gaps: No combo data supplied (0 combos, 0 appearances): cannot empirically measure board-building power, appearance percentage, or average power index when present. No banlist detail: assumed unlimited copies based on empty legal copies field. No starter/extender role breakdown in deck evidence: cannot quantify initiation vs extension frequency. Single guide source (Vietnamese only): no English meta commentary or competitive context. No 'top card' ranking: cannot confirm meta-level performance or win-rate correlation. No rulings documentation: assumed standard XYZ/bounce mechanics, but timing edge cases unexplored.






